Something strange is happening in local marketing. Business owners who've spent years building their Google presence, collecting reviews, and running ads are discovering a blind spot they never planned for: AI search.
When someone opens ChatGPT, Perplexity, or Google's AI Overview and asks "best Italian restaurant in Scottsdale" or "top-rated dentist near me," the AI doesn't pull from the same playbook as traditional search. And if your business isn't in the answer, that customer just went to your competitor without ever seeing your name.
How AI Search Engines Actually Find Businesses
Large language models like ChatGPT don't crawl Google Maps or read your Yelp reviews in real time. They were trained on massive datasets of web content: articles, directories, news sites, blog posts, and structured data from across the internet.
When someone asks for a recommendation, the AI synthesizes what it "knows" from that training data. Businesses that show up are the ones that were mentioned frequently, in authoritative contexts, with enough detail for the model to understand what they do and where they operate.
Why Domain Authority and Content Depth Matter More Than Ever
Here's what separates businesses that appear in AI recommendations from those that don't:
- Content depth: Your website needs more than a homepage and a contact page. AI models need rich, detailed content about your services, your location, your expertise, and what makes you different.
- Third-party mentions: Being cited on other websites, local directories, news articles, and industry blogs signals to AI that you're a real, established business.
- Structured data: Schema markup helps AI models parse your business information accurately: your name, address, services, hours, and categories.
- Topical authority: Businesses that publish helpful content about their industry build a knowledge footprint that AI models reference when making recommendations.
What a Low AI Visibility Score Actually Means
At MAISEL, we test this directly. We ask AI models the exact questions your potential customers are asking and check whether your business appears in the response. Your AI Visibility Score reflects how often you show up across multiple relevant queries.
A low score doesn't mean your business is bad. It means the internet doesn't have enough of the right content about your business for AI to recommend you confidently. The good news: this is fixable.
Get The Root delivered weekly
We respect your privacy. Unsubscribe at any time.
What You Can Do About It
Improving your AI visibility starts with understanding where the gaps are. Here's a quick framework:
- Audit your web presence: Is your business mentioned on authoritative third-party sites beyond just directories?
- Expand your content: Add detailed service pages, location pages, FAQ sections, and blog posts that answer the questions your customers actually ask.
- Add schema markup: Make sure your structured data is complete and accurate so AI can parse your business details.
- Build citations: Get mentioned in local news, industry publications, and relevant blogs.
The businesses winning in AI search aren't doing anything revolutionary. They're just doing the fundamentals with more depth and consistency than their competitors.
Find out your AI Visibility Score with a free, instant report from MAISEL. We'll test your business against real AI queries, scan your competitors, and show you exactly where you stand.
See Where Your Business Ranks
Get a free competitive intelligence report. We analyze your website, scan your competitors, and test your AI search visibility — ready in 60 seconds.
Run My Analysis →
